Reconstruction Error of Calibration Volume's Coordinates for 3D Swimming Kinematics
Languages of publication
The aim of this study was to investigate the accuracy and reliability of above and underwater 3D reconstruction of three calibration volumes with different control points disposal (#1 - on vertical and horizontal rods; #2 - on vertical and horizontal rods and facets; #3 - on crossed horizontal rods). Each calibration volume (3 × 2 × 3 m) was positioned in a 25 m swimming pool (half above and half below the water surface) and recorded with four underwater and two above water synchronised cameras (50 Hz). Reconstruction accuracy was determined calculating the RMS error of twelve validation points. The standard deviation across all digitisation of the same marker was used for assessing the reliability estimation. Comparison among different number of control points showed that the set of 24 points produced the most accurate results. The volume #2 presented higher accuracy (RMS errors: 5.86 and 3.59 mm for × axis, 3.45 and 3.11 mm for y axis and 4.38 and 4.00 mm for z axis, considering under and above water, respectively) and reliability (SD: underwater cameras ± [0.2; 0.6] mm; above water cameras ± [0.2; 0.3] mm) that may be considered suitable for 3D swimming kinematic analysis. Results revealed that RMS error was greater during underwater analysis, possibly due to refraction.
1 - 9 - 2011
4 - 10 - 2011
- Abdel-Aziz Y, Karara H. Direct linear transformation: from comparator coordinates into object coordinates in close range photogrammetry. In Proceedings of the symposium on close-range photogrammetry. Illinois: Church Falls, 1971, pp. 1-18.
- Allard P, Blanchi JP, Aissaoui R. Bases of three-dimensional reconstruction. In P Allard, IAF Stokes, JP Blanchi (Eds.), Three-dimensional analysis of human movement. Champaign: Human Kinetics, 1995, pp. 19-40.
- Berger M, Hollander AP, De Groot G. Determining propulsive force in front crawl swimming: A comparison of two methods. J Sports Sci, 1999; 17: 97-105.[Crossref]
- Cappaert JM, Pease DL, Troup JP. Three-dimensional analysis of the men's 100-m freestyle during the 1992 Olympic Games. J Appl Biomech, 1995; 11: 103-112.
- Challis JH. A multiphase calibration procedure for the direct linear transformation. J Appl Biomech, 1995; 11: 351-358.
- Challis JH, Kerwin DG. Accuracy assessment and control point configuration when using the DLT for photogrammetry. J Biomech, 1992; 25: 1053-1058.[PubMed][Crossref]
- Chen L, Armstrong CW, Raftopoulos DD. An investigation on the accuracy of three-dimensional space reconstruction using the direct linear transformation technique. J Biomech, 1994; 27: 493-500.[PubMed][Crossref]
- Coleman SG, Rankin AJ. A three-dimensional examination of the planar nature of the golf swing. J Sports Sci, 2005; 23: 227-234.[Crossref]
- Figueiredo P, Vilas Boas JP, Maia J, Goncalves P, Fernandes RJ. Does the hip reflect the centre of mass swimming kinematics? Int J Sports Med, 2009; 30: 779-781.[WoS][PubMed][Crossref]
- Gourgoulis V, Aggeloussis N, Kasimatis P, Vezos N, Boli A, Mavromatis G. Reconstruction accuracy in underwater three-dimensional kinematic analysis. J Sc Med Sport, 2008; 11: 90-95.[WoS][Crossref]
- Hopkins WG. Measures of reliability in sports medicine and science. Sports Med, 2000; 30 :1-15.[PubMed][Crossref]
- Kwon YH. Object plane deformation due to refraction in two-dimensional underwater motion analysis. J Appl Biomech, 1999; 15: 396-403.
- Kwon YH, Casebolt JB. Effects of light refraction on the accuracy of camera calibration and reconstruction in underwater motion analysis. Sports Biomech, 2006; 5: 315-340.[PubMed][Crossref]
- Kwon YH, Kwak CS. Development on an inverse-periscope for underwater motion analysis in swimming. J Sports Sci, 1996; 7: 1-7.
- Kwon YH, Lindley S. Applicability of 4 localized-calibration methods in underwater motion analysis. In Y Hong, D Johns, R Sanders (Eds.), Proceedings of XVIII international symposium on biomechanics in sports. Hong Kong, 2000, pp. 48-55.
- Kwon YH, Moon YJ, Lee JS. Application of the DLT method to the underwater motion analysis. J Sport Biomech, 1995; 5: 49-54.
- Lam TC, Frank CB, Shrive NG. Calibration characteristics of a video dimension analyser (VDA) system. J Biomech, 1992; 25 :1227-1231.[PubMed][Crossref]
- Lauder MA, Dabnichki P, Bartlett RM. Three-dimensional reconstruction accuracy within a calibrated volume. In S Haake (Ed.), The engineering of sport: design and development. United Kingdom: Blackwell Science, 1998, pp. 441-448.
- Lauder MA, Dabnichki P, Bartlett RM, Aritan S. The accuracy of kinematic data collected from underwater three-dimensional analysis. In S Haake (Ed.) The engineering of sport. Rotterdam: A A Balkema, 1996, pp. 303-312.
- Payton C, Baltzopoulos V, Bartlett R. Contributions of rotations of the trunk and upper extremity to hand velocity during front crawl swimming. J Appl Biomech, 2002; 18: 243-256.
- Payton CJ, Bartlett RM. Estimating propulsive forces in swimming from three-dimensional kinematic data. J Sports Sci, 1995; 13: 447-454.[Crossref]
- Psycharakis S, Sanders R, Mill F. A calibration frame for 3D swimming analysis. In Q Wang (Ed.), Proceedings of the XXIII International Symposium on Biomechanics in Sports. Beijing: The China Institute of Sports Sciences, 2005, pp. 901-904.
- Shapiro R. Direct linear transformation method for three-dimensional cinematography. Res Q Exerc Sport, 1978; 49 :197-205.
- Scheirman G, Porter J, Leigh M, Musick M. An integrated method to obtain three-dimensional coordinates using panning and tilting video cameras. In HJ Riehle, MM Viete (Eds.), Proceedings XVI international symposium on biomechanics in sports. Konstanz, 1998, pp. 567-569.
- Yanai T, Hay JG, Gerot JT. Three-dimensional videography of swimming with panning periscopes. J Biomech, 1996; 29: 673-678.[PubMed][Crossref]
Publication order reference