Caveat patiens - ethical dilemmas in decision -making

• Authors: June McKoy , Judith McKoy
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

More than 99,358 men, women and children are on organ transplant lists in the United States. Pressure on family members to donate organs can therefore be intense. The medical excuse was created to address this potential coercion. It is a fabricated anatomical or physiological reason given to a donor (with or without the donor’s request) that provides an immediate shield against coercive pressure by family and friends on the potential donor. While the long-term risks and benefits of the medical excuse have not been studied, they could arguably include: 1) Reinforced perception that donation is expected; hence, declining donation is aberrant, and requires legitimization by external authority; 2) Eroded family trust of transplant physicians; 3) Eroded family trust in the individual reporting a “true” medical excuse; 4) Falsification of potential donor’s medical record; 5) Development of “toxic secrets” in the family unit; 6) Paternalism; and 7) General erosion of trust in both health care providers and the healthcare system. This author proposes a system of transparent and balanced communication where both the potential donor and the transplant team are clearly cognizant of the voluntary nature of the purported donation and where provisions for “opting-out” occur at any point along the pre-transplantation continuum.

Keywords

EN

Medical excuse; Ethics; Transplant; Organ donation; Decision making

• Publisher: De Gruyter Open
• Journal: Open Medicine
• Year: 2008
• Volume: 3
• Issue: 4
• Pages: 390-395

Dates

published

1 - 12 - 2008

online

22 - 10 - 2008

Contributors

author

June McKoy

• Department of Medicine, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, IL, 60611, Chicago, USA

author

Judith McKoy

• Department of Medicine, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, IL, 60611, Chicago, USA

References

• [1] Spital A., Taylor J.S., Living organ donation: always ethically complex, Clin. J. Am. Soc. Nephrol., 2007, 2, 203–4 http://dx.doi.org/10.2215/CJN.04011206[Crossref]
• [2] Mackler A.L., Respecting Bodies and Saving Lives: Jewish Perspectives on Organ Donation and Transplantation. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 2001, 10, 420–429 http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0963180101004066[Crossref]
• [3] Sachedina A.A., Islamic views on organ transplantation, Transplant. Proc., 1988, 20 (suppl 1), 1084–1088 [PubMed]
• [4] El-Shahat Y.I.M., Islamic viewpoint of organ transplantation, Transplant. Proc., 1999, 31, 3271–3274 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0041-1345(99)00721-6[Crossref]
• [5] Scorsone S., Christianity and the significance of the human body, Transplant. Proc., 1990, 22, 943–944 [PubMed]
• [6] Bynum C.W., Fragmentation and Redemption: Essays on Gender and the Human Body in Medieval Religions, Zone Books, New York, NY, 1991
• [7] Lysaught M.T., Contesting the boundary between life and death: organ transplantation and the identity of the Christian community, J. Health Care Chaplain., 1993, 5, 73–89 http://dx.doi.org/10.1300/J080v05n01_08[Crossref]
• [8] Delmonic F.L., Sheehy E., Marks W.H., Baliga P., McGowan J.J., Magee J.C., Organ donation and utilization in the United States, 2004, Am. J. Transplant., 2005, 5, 862–873 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-6135.2005.00832.x[Crossref]
• [9] Morrissey P.E., Monaco A.P., Living kidney donation: evolution and technical aspects of donor nephrectomy, Surg. Clin. North Am., 2006, 86, 1219–35. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.suc.2006.06.008[Crossref]
• [10] Surman O.S., The ethics of partial-liver donation, N. Engl. J. Med., 2002, 346, 1038 http://dx.doi.org/10.1056/NEJM200204043461402[Crossref]
• [11] Berg J., Appelbaum P.S., Lidz C.W., Parker L.S., Informed Consent: Legal Theory and Clinical Practice, 2nd ed., Oxford University Press, New York, 2001
• [12] Kallich J.D., Merz J.F., The Transplant Imperative: Protecting Living Donors from the Pressure to Donate, 20 J. CORP. L., 1995, 139
• [13] Caplan A., Biomedical Technology, Ethics, and the Law: Am I My Brother’s Keeper? 27 Suffolk University Law Review, 1993, 1195
• [14] Laura A., Siminoff. The Fallacy of the Gift of Life, Hastings Center Report, 1999, 29, 6, 31–41
• [15] Fox R.C., Swazey J.P., The Courage to Fail: A Social View of Organ Transplants and Dialysis, 2nd ed., rev., University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 345–375, 1978
• [16] Ashraf H., Doctor and patient groups vote for presumed consent, Lancet, 1999, 354, 230 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(05)66303-9[Crossref]
• [17] Fox R.C., Swazey J.P., Spare parts: organ replacement in American Society, Oxford University Press, New York, 1992
• [18] Ekholm I., Kidney Donors Don’t Regret, Transplantation, 2000, 69, 2067–2070 http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/00007890-200005270-00016[Crossref]
• [19] Beauchamp T. L., Childress J. F., Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 5th ed., Oxford University Press, New York, NY, 2001
• [20] DeMarco J.P., Principlism and moral dilemmas: a new principle, J. Med. Ethics, 2005, 31, 101–105 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/jme.2004.007856[Crossref]
• [21] Trianosky G., Velazco Y., What is Virtue ethics All About? American Philosophical Quarterly, 1990, 27, 335–44, reprinted in Statman, 1997
• [22] Nolan M.T., Ethical dilemmas in living donor organ transplantation, J. Transpl Coord., 1999, 9, 225–9 [PubMed]

Identifiers

DOI

10.2478/s11536-008-0048-4